top of page

Why Well-Intended Feedback Still Fails.  And What To Do About It.

4 hours ago
6 min read

Angela Lane and Sergey Gorbatov


Ask a leader whether they’ve given performance feedback, and most will say yes. Ask whether anything sustainably changed, and the answer is usually no.


Feedback works when it gives someone a reason to act: the recipient knows, specifically, what they need to do differently and what they’ll gain from acting on the feedback.


More often than not, performance feedback doesn’t result in positive change.  Kluger and DeNisi’s famous 1996 meta-analysis found that feedback raised performance on average and made it worse in more than a third of cases. 


In practice, we see a repeated cause. Like a stool, successful performance feedback stands on three legs. Take one away, and it falls over, however well-intended and however well delivered.


The three legs

The FairTalk model of effective feedback describes the three ingredients that make feedback effective. 


  1. “Tell me why it matters.” Feedback should be connected to a result the person cares about.

  2. “Tell me how I’m doing.” Feedback needs to make it explicit whether expectations are being met, exceeded, or falling short. Said plainly.

  3. “Tell me what to do.” Performance feedback needs to make any expectation of change clear. “I expect you to…” not “It would be nice if you…” or “Have you thought about…?”


When you think of these three as legs of a stool, it is obvious that if you skip one, the result is, at best, shaky.  At worst, things fall over. 


What happens when a leg of your stool is missing

Let’s take an example.   Consider a Finance Director whose weekly forecast consistently arrives after the deadline. Her manager raises it three ways, each one missing one leg of the stool. 


Unclear “why”. “Your weekly forecast is late. I expect the forecast by noon, each Friday before the new week begins.” The Finance Director complies for two weeks. Then, when the quarter-end also hits, the Friday “forecast delivered before noon” drops. 


The research that explains this drop in performance is found in Ellen Langer’s study of people standing in line to use a photocopier. Ask if you can push into the line to do a quick copy, and those waiting typically say yes. You can give them any reason for cutting in, even a lame one. But ask a big favour; that is, you want to break into the line with a whole lot of copying to do, and only a persuasive reason will move people to comply. Asking someone to change how they work is like asking a big favour. Change and development are hard. You better give a good reason.  


Unclear “how I’m doing”. What happens when the “why” is clear, but the performance feedback dodges the difficult part of the conversation- that today’s performance just isn’t cutting it.  


“The Executive Team adjusts manufacturing volume and inventory, based on an analysis which includes your forecast. When the forecast is incomplete, we can miss potential revenue or incur higher cost of goods. It’s important that we meet the standard when it comes to forecasting.” Our Finance Director is left worried and probably guessing: what does the "standard” mean? The absence of clarity that the expectation is consistent, on-time reporting and that they are failing to meet the standard doesn’t tell the receiver where they stand.  


Left to guess how big the gap is, they will most likely do nothing, which undermines the general sense of the importance of forecasting.  The more diligent may over-correct, or even focus on the wrong thing, like incremental forecast accuracy, without being able to make sense of exactly what expectation is being missed.  


Unclear “what to do”. What does it look like to miss the third leg?  What happens if we leave an employee unclear about what action to take? 


“The weekly forecast is critical.  The Executive Team plans, based on your forecast, and you aren’t meeting expectations today regarding timeliness.  So don't disappoint me again.” In this case, it is clear that forecasting is important and that expectations aren’t being met.  But no helpful expectation is set for what action needs to be taken.  To “not disappoint” is an outcome, of sorts, we suppose.   But it doesn’t tell the employee how they can improve performance. For example, an agreement that the employee will start the forecasting process earlier in weeks that include quarter reporting.  


In every case, the manager gave feedback, and nothing changed.  It could look different.  


All three. 


“Having the forecast on time is important: the Executive Team uses the consolidated forecasts each week to adjust the forecast in the sales and operations plan.  That plan determines manufacturing and inventory, which impact revenue and margin.  Your last forecast arrived two days late, despite the known deadline.  That doesn’t meet the performance expectations we have for Directors. This appears to be a problem when the forecast falls at the same time as the quarterly report. I expect you to find ways to ensure that both are done on time, and we can discuss those.  Immediately, I want you to dedicate Friday mornings to completing the forecast and have it to me by noon.  That gives us a buffer, so I can support you if you are behind.”  


The three-legged stool isn’t a guarantee of performance improvement.  The research confirms that feedback with all three legs can still fail, for example, when the person disagrees with the feedback, or when they lack the skill they need to perform. But feedback missing one of these elements rarely works, even when self-awareness and skill are there.


The test

If you are giving feedback and you aren’t getting the results you expect, a simple place to start is to ask three questions.


• Does the person understand why this matters?  Do they understand how their work connects to a bigger purpose, contributes to a shared outcome, or impacts their reputation?  And so on.  After all, if you can’t explain why it matters, it probably doesn’t!  


• Do they know how they’re doing?  This aspect of feedback benefits when the gap is described as specifically as possible and clearly identified as a deficit.  We all have opportunities to improve.  Telling someone they have a deficit makes it clear that something must change.  


• Do they know what to do now?  Here, we may appear to depart from the often-preferred coaching approach. We don’t apologise.  In the context of performance feedback, the leader's obligation is to correct performance issues.  Coaching for even higher performance can follow.  But waiting until someone figures it out for themselves isn't fair to the business or the employee. 


So, name the missing leg of the stool, and go back and supply it. 


What to do now 

For Leaders: use these three questions to prepare for a feedback conversation. It is a very simple framework.   And if your feedback doesn’t land, run through them again before going back to expand the missing leg.


For HR Leaders: teach the three steps of powerful feedback to managers. Leaders don’t need a complex framework, a certification or a day off-site. They need three simple steps they can hold in their head. And if they aren’t getting the results they need, use the same questions to diagnose why feedback may have failed.  Apply the approach across the organisation.  


For Both: Know that when you give feedback, you aren’t only improving performance most of the time.  You are creating a better place to work for employees.  A Gallup study confirmed the link between feedback quality and engagement: 80% of employees who say they received meaningful feedback in the past week are fully engaged.

So, if you want performance and employee engagement, why not revisit the last piece of feedback that went nowhere? Ask yourself: which leg of the stool are you missing?


Sources

• Kluger, A. N. & DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance. Psychological Bulletin, 119, 254–284.

• Langer, E. J., Blank, A., & Chanowitz, B. (1978). The mindlessness of ostensibly thoughtful action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 36(6), 635–642.

• McLain, D., & Nelson, B. (2022). How Effective Feedback Fuels Performance. Gallup.

The views expressed are those of the authors and do not represent the views of any institutions with which they are affiliated.


The views expressed here are the authors. They are not the views of any associated organisations.


 
 
 

Comments


Stay Connected

Subscribe to be getting updates on our research and thinking

Thanks for submitting!

Follow us on Instagram

  • Instagram

© 2020 All rights reserved           Privacy Policy

Contact us

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page