top of page

Succession Planning ... let me re-think that...

12 minutes ago
6 min read


“Trying to predict the future is like trying to drive down a country road at night with no lights while looking out the back window."   Peter Drucker  




A few years ago, we made a prediction. In a fast-changing world, where jobs change faster than people, the practice of succession planning would, of nec

essity, need to evolve from the “name in the box” to systems that deploy the best available talent, at speed, and focus on providing deep expertise in surrounding successors with the infrastructure they need to perform. Preparing people for specific jobs, jobs that were evolving fast, wouldn’t make sense in the way it used to.  


We haven’t revisited this topic formally, but if we are honest, we would probably have hypothesized that AI would only make this forecast more reasonable.  


Ask us again this week! 


Nvidia’s Jensen Huang resigned as CEO last Thursday, amid reports of an alleged affair and a China-linked national security probe. The stock fell as much as 12% on the news. There was no successor. The CFO is now doing both jobs.  By his own account, Huang did not believe in succession planning, and the board never forced the issue.  

It is easy to be distracted by the scandal surrounding this situation. (Think Coldplay “kiss cam”, which ended a CEO’s tenure in three days. The company, Astronomer, relied on their co-founder to step into the breach, but we digress.)


For us, the real issue of interest is the action of investors. 


A Nvidia shareholder filed a derivative suit against Huang and the board the day the board accepted his resignation. “The board has long deferred to Mr. Huang. … and the Board has let him resist adopting a CEO succession plan.”   

The investor issue is real.  


Think Disney. A few years ago the Disney board ousted their CEO, to bring Bob Iger back. Their succession process, Disney had one, had produced a successor. It did not prevent activist investor Nelson Peltz going on public record to say the Board had failed in its duty, by failing to properly plan for succession, a part of a campaign to get the activist a seat on Disney's board, based on the need for, amongst other things, improved governance:


“The Board botched its most important job, CEO succession, by installing Bob Chapek in that role seemingly without appropriate vetting or oversight."  [Trian Fund Management, L.P. (2024, March 25).Trian Fund Management (Nelson Peltz), March 25, 2024] 


The Disney board then ran a succession process from January 2023 with a dedicated committee and unanimously elected Josh D’Amaro, effective 18 March 2026. Peltz still went to the Wall Street Journal claiming Iger steered the choice to keep power. Rigor reduces the attack surface but does not remove it.


It’s a continuum

How can both things be true. That is it hard to predict the content of roles, and the context of the business, on a time line that is long enough to actually allow for experiential development, while recognising the responsibility to ensure continuity, in particular, where the risk is likely to be to business results and, through investor action, personal Board member accountability. A board with no alternative ends up negotiating with the person it just removed. Disney did it in 2022; Nvidia is in the middle of something similar with the “Stand With Jensen” campaign.


What has always been true is that succession planning, as practiced, represents something of a continuum. 


  1. Administrative Check the Box. Companies have a plan, but it is not vetted, and there is no accountability if a box sits without a successor, or without choice of successors, for years.

  2. Compliance. Completed. Companies have a plan, and the Board reviews it. The Board expects it to be completed, but may not be in a position to assess its quality. 

  3. Rigor Realized. Companies identify and develop successors.  They expect quality, so they have processes in place, typically annual, including testing or validating successors.  Boards interrogate the process rigour, so they can have confidence in it.  This is where many strong companies sit, and it is genuinely good.

  4. Strategic succession. Companies build on an already rigorous process by differentiating succession investment according to strategic priorities and enterprise risk. They identify roles where leadership failure would have disproportionate consequences, suitable talent is scarce, or the time required to develop alternatives is significant. Succession planning contemplates different business conditions, such as high growth, turnaround, business model transformation, diversification, etc. and builds credible leadership choices for each. It also identifies and develops enterprise talent whose potential extends beyond their current function. Because it focuses on a small number of roles, it allows decision makers to consider both individual decisions and the mix of leaders.  Succession planning is not just for the role, but for the team.  As strategy evolves, succession options are continuously reassessed, with the Board actively engaged in understanding the candidates, the choices, the trade-offs and risks.


Done well, succession is invisible. Sonoco announced its CEO Howard Coker’s retirement and an internal successor, Ernest Haynes, on 9 November, three days before Nvidia. Nobody noticed, which is the point. 


In contrast, succession failure draws shareholder suits, activist letters, compensation consequences, and a public profile that most HR practices never see. It can take billions off a market cap in a day.  What we described as scrambling is better described as dynamic. We said you cannot prepare people for jobs that keep changing. We still think so. But as the future gets closer, the succession board is dynamically recast, not annually, but continuously aligned with strategy, and validated by expectations of candidate improvement. 


CEO succession belongs to the board. Everything below belongs to the CEO and HR. The same continuum applies to both.  


A practical approach 

The idea of a continuum is helpful.  A HR leader can use it to identify:

  • Where are we? Be honest about which stage describes what you actually do, not what the policy says.

  • Where do we need to be in general?  This is about recognizing that not every company needs Stage 4 succession planning across every role. This is about asking what is the minimum standard required to manage succession risk.  The mistake is applying the same standard everywhere by default.  And knowing where the minimum is not enough.  

  • Where do we need to be in the areas aligned to our strategic goals? HR has traditionally applied a one size fits most approach to succession planning, creating a process which, in some cases, delivers limited strategic value. A differentiated approach starts by identifying the roles that matter most to enterprise strategy, considering the consequences of leadership failure, the scarcity of suitable talent and the time required to develop credible alternatives. Strategic, differentiated HR identifies individuals who have the potential to create value across these roles. Other roles can be managed through appropriately rigorous, but less resource-intensive processes, including external hiring. The resources released are redirected toward building leadership choices that will matter most to future performance.


A practical approach.  In practice 

Consider a company with 50 senior leadership roles. Rather than applying the same succession process to all 50, it differentiates its investment based on strategic importance and succession risk. Four roles emerge as disproportionately consequential to enterprise performance, given the potential impact of leadership failure, scarcity of suitable talent, and time required to develop credible alternatives. These roles receive substantially greater scrutiny, with successors evaluated against different strategic scenarios and internal AND external options actively maintained. At the same time, the company identifies a select pool of high-potential enterprise leaders whose capabilities could create value across multiple roles and functions. Their development and deployment are managed centrally, supported by dedicated talent resources, targeted experiences and direct senior leadership sponsorship, regardless of their functional home. Another 15 roles warrant rigorous but more conventional succession planning, while the remaining 31 are managed through lighter-touch processes; potential candidates are identified, including in case of emergency, and expected to have a development plan. 


As strategy evolves, the priority roles, succession options and investment decisions are continuously reassessed. The objective is not 50 completed succession plans, but credible, vetted leadership choices where they matter most, with investment directed toward protecting and creating enterprise value.


The future of succession planning

No succession plan would have prevented last week. A plan would have decided what happened next. But in light of what's happened at Nvidia, we fully acknowledge that we may have underestimated the consequences of getting it wrong. This week we saw 500 billion reasons to rethink.  

The increasing pace of change makes predicting future leadership requirements harder, not easier. Yet the obligation to ensure leadership continuity, protect enterprise value and provide credible choices has never been more important.

The answer isn't more succession planning. It is more strategic succession planning: differentiated investment, enterprise-wide talent choices, and the ability to adapt as business conditions change.

The future may be impossible to predict. But that is precisely why we need choices.


Angela and Sergey 


PS: If you would like to learn more about the succession continuum and how to identify your current state, reach out to me by DM, and I’ll send you more information.  Sergey 


The opinions expressed here are those of the authors, and not the organizations with which they are proudly associated. 


 
 
 

Comments


Stay Connected

Subscribe to be getting updates on our research and thinking

Thanks for submitting!

Follow us on Instagram

  • Instagram

© 2020 All rights reserved           Privacy Policy

Contact us

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page